Wednesday, 7 September 2011

Problems of Indian Democracy and its ultimate solution, A Vision....

“Democracy: a system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state, typically through elected representatives”
Today we are facing challenges that are bigger than us: the climate crisis, the financial crisis, terrorism etc-etc. Our governments are mainly unable to cope with these new challenges. For the majority of them, they are stuck with short term decisions. They spend tax payers’ money to save failed institution.
We need to rethink our democracies
Our Occidental democracies are based on paper. Political parties are sending their program on paper. Citizens vote on paper. But paper is expensive. Paper takes time to be printed and more importantly paper are essentially a one-way communication channels.
As a result, citizens can only vote every 5 years or so. In the time in between, they have little interaction with their representatives. As our memories used to be short, they can basically do whatever except during the last 6 months before an election.
In current democracies, there are almost no interaction with citizens and with expert. Collaboration is limited.

Voting paper can’t be personalized
On top of that, paper cannot be personalized. Every single citizen, whether he is a worker or a non-worker, a youngster or an old person, get the same paper. They all have to answer the same questions. They all have to vote for the same people. And as every human, these people are good for some subjects but can’t be good for solving all the different issues we are facing as a society.
I would love that our governments ask us much more our thinking. But they can’t do it on paper. It is too expensive and they would need to spend too much time to educate the whole population to make sure they can take a good decision (look at all the debates about the European Constitution in France!).
What I want is a clever democracy. I don’t wanna be asked about what to do regarding agriculture policies (I’m not a farmer), I don’t wanna be asked about what to do to foster entrepreneurship, But, I do wanna be asked about what to do regarding education at this time, about what to do make our educational institutions more efficient(As I m a student). For the rest, I trust my fellow citizens who are more directly impacted or have time to dig into the subject.
You can’t ask to everybody their thinking about everything. But this remains unthinkable in our current democracies.
It’s not about left and right wing anymore, it’s about communities
People used to gather behind this simple paradigm: you are whether a socialist (left wing) or a liberal (right wing). But this leads to useless competition and decisions based on the politic party you support instead of your real skills to fit the job as a leader.
This means that our leaders don’t have to collaborate with the best people out there to make our society work better. They have to compete, they have to be winners and make the other lose next elections.

In a Democracy 2.0, Citizens could participate in chosen topics
From parliament members to community managers
What we need is leaders that will collaborate with people expert in their field. We need leaders who won’t pretend to be able to give answers to all subjects of our society. Tomorrow’s new leaders need be closer of their communities. They need to foster the debates, be more transparent, in one word; they need to be “Community managers”.

In a Democracy 2.0, parliament members should ask as Community Managers

Democracy 1.0 relies on paper, Democracy 2.0 will use the Internet as the new paper
Today we have a new technology at hand: The Internet. For the first time in human history, we can put together a majority of citizens through a two-way communication channel. Why not using this to build a new paradigm of democracy?
It is cheap and it allows personalisation. Citizens would be able to choose in which subjects they are mostly interested. They will not be bothered with unfamiliar topics. But they will have a lot of things to say to things which would impact them directly.
Hope, I am clear wid ma vision but still waiting a valuable comments of u all friends....

(Awantika Sen)


  1. good analysis awani....

  2. wah kya khojparak jaankaari uplabh karwaaya hai...dhanyavaad..

  3. "@ --The Internet. For the first time in human history, we can put together a majority of citizens through a two-way communication channel. Why not using this to build a new paradigm of democracy?" - Well, if you do further analysis, then you will find that most of the voters are from the rural area where the internet or other technologies are widely not available or most of them dont know how to use most the gram panchayat in India been provided with the internet,still uneducated and illiterate person they dont know how to use it.. secondly - you need to understand the rural politics system, its based of caste/community leaders and top of that whome their forefathers supported(mostly you will find congress supporters , but recently sifted to communal based and caste based (muslim,hindu and SC/ST/OBC ) .. so internet can be used to spread message to the educated/internet society, and that to even they start their discussion on net and ends it on net ... still its good to give a start.. but remember one thing..their is no place of emotions and feelings in politics ... so one have to be strong and bold enough to take the mass movement ahead... good luck and best wishes to u ...



  5. achchi jankaari dene ke liye dhanywaad,,,,par english me hone ke karan jyada samajh me nahi aaya...
    jai hind jai bharat

  6. @Dinesh, I would like to introduce u to the pilot project of Indian Government, "Gramin Broadband Conectivity Yojana". It is said that under this scheem Gov. of India 'll link all 2.5 Lac Village Panchayats' to the internet broadband connectivity till 2014.
    So, no longer it is, our villagers too 'll feel convenient to use this mode communication.
    Thanking You,
    Awantika Sen.

  7. निशांत,
    अपने अगले पोस्ट मे मै इसका ध्यान रखूंगी और मेरा पूरा प्रयत्न हिंदी को प्रश्रय का होगा. मै आपकी आभारी हूँ. आपने मुझे पढ़ा.
    कोटिशः धन्यवाद,
    अवंतिका सेन.

  8. I m pleased of u Sir, Arvind & Sir, Alok punj that u consider this post is of value.
    wid warm regards,
    Awantika Sen.

  9. कुमार आलोक,
    सराहना के लिए आपका आभार व्यक्त करती हूँ.
    अवंतिका सेन.

  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

  11. I just accidentally encountered the blog, but I must say that it's worth reading your posts (yes, I also read the first one)... I really like the idea of Democracy 2.0, however, at the same time I am very disappointed after reading your second post that instead of cleaning the dirt you just want to run away... I know you are not that kind of gal (but your last post made me to believe the same)... and to be very frank I am quite impressed by your thoughts... I just want you to be strong and use the Internet or other Social Channels to represent the feelings of youth in the country... I assume you are strong though I have not the idea about your leadership skills, but I am ready to take the chances... WISH YOU BEST OF LUCK!!!!!!

    BTW I think I got too much emotional, but I am still sharing my feelings here...